Tuesday, May 3, 2011

The Gap Theory - Genesis 1:1-2

Genesis 1:1-2 has been translated by the King James Version as follows:

 1In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.
 2And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.
The problem with these verses is not readily identifiable by a surface examination of the text. The problem we are facing here is the artificial insertion of the period between verses one and two. This insertion has led to a number of theories that appear to ignore the actual Hebrew in the verses. Further, the period between verses one and two has been used by theistic evolutionists and "old earth" creationists as a basis for a "gap theory" or to shoehorn modern atheistic evolution into the text of the Bible. The problem is that the Hebrew does not appear to allow for the period or the insertion of billions of years into the God's creation process.

Dr. Robert Morey has translated these verses as follows:
When the Beginning began, out of nothing, God created the heavens and the earth, and the earth was devoid of life and a desert, and darkness covered the surface of the sea, and the Spirit of God was brooding over the surface of the water.
 What must be pointed out is that verse two is a series of three vav consecutives (rendered "and" in English). According to Dr. Morey's translation, the vav consecutives indicate that verses one and two are actually one sentence in the Hebrew. What the King James version translators did in artificially inserting the period between verses one and two is set their misinterpretation in stone for all subsequent English translations of the Bible. This is not the only verse in the King James Version that they did this to. I must point out, however, that whether verse one and verse two are translated into one or two sentences this does not affect the doctrine of creation.

This artificial division has led to the establishment of the "gap theory". This theory, proposed by well intentioned Christians who hope to shoehorn the geological record into the first two verses of Genesis by positing that there was a undetermined period of time between verse one of Genesis chapter one and verse two. This theory can still be found in the Scofield Reference Bible, the Dake's Annotated Bible and some other Bible study aids.The "gap theory" is also promoted by Dr. Hugh Ross of the Institute for Creation Research.

One of the problems created by the "gap theory" is the insertion of pre-Adamic humanoids. This attempt at synthesizing the assertions of atheistic evolutionists with the Biblical record does not work. Namely, because Genesis 2:7 does not say "the living creature became a man" but that "the man became a living creature."

In conclusion I wish to say that I do not believe that whether a believer is an "old earth" creationist or a "young earth" creationist is an essential over which Christians should break fellowship. I realize that there are many who may disagree with me on this point, and you are entitled to that view. With that said, I do wish to point out that the use of Genesis 1:1 & 2 as a foundation for an "old earth" view is playing fast and loose with the Scriptures. I believe that a serious exegesis of the Scriptures will necessitate a "young earth" view of this planet by a Christian that is serious about studying the Bible.

Saturday, April 23, 2011

Resurrection Sunday 2011

Resurrection Sunday is not about what Jesus can do for you or your broken dreams, but it is about what Jesus did for you. Romans 4:24-25 says, "...us who believe in Him who raised from the dead Jesus our Lord, who was delivered up for our trespasses and raised for our justification." This is what Jesus' death and resurrection accomplished for Christians. There are a number of pastors out there that will not be teaching this tomorrow. Instead they will be teaching about a phony Jesus whose death and resurrection has only temporal benefits. They teach this sort of resurrection message because they are not interested in teaching the sheep, but attracting goats (Matthew 25:32). The reason is simple, too many pastors are concerned about having "mega-churches" and million dollar budgets. They fixate on "five-star" amenities, not to benefit the sheep, but to make the goats comfortable. The problem with this is that it is unscriptural. One of the marks of a healthy church is not the amenities, but the teaching.

Too many of these pastors that are fixated with numbers (attenders & finances) do not preach the Gospel. Instead they preach about how the problems (they don't preach about sin) in their lives are the fault of others who damaged them emotionally, or the fault of the white man. The Bible teaches, however, that the main problem with humanity is that it is radically fallen into sin. Paul, in Romans 3:9-20, clearly states the facts regarding humanity's internal malady and the symptoms that this malady manifests. Paul concludes this chapter by stating in verse 19, that all the sins he listed in the previous nine verses were manifestations of humanity's lawlessness which shuts their mouths, and for which they will be held accountable to God.

This message is not palatable to the unregenerate. They prefer to blame the evil they do on damaged emotions, poor environment, lack of education or something else. The problem with this blame shifting is that it makes no difference if a person has damaged emotions, a poor environment or is uneducated because we see example after example of people coming from good environments, with ample education, and with healthy emotions doing horrible things. The problem is not rotted in these issues, but instead rooted in the fact that humanity is radically fallen into sin.

Humanity's sinfulness is described in a number of Bible verses. Genesis 6:5 states that humanity's wickedness was great and that every intention of humanity's thoughts was only evil continually. You may say that this verse describes pre-Flood humanity, and does not apply to us after the Flood. I simply point you to Genesis 8:21 which says that the intention of man's heart is evil from his youth. Jeremiah 17:9 says that the human heart, the seat of reason in Hebrew thought, "is deceitful above all things and desperately sick".

Humanity's sinfulness is so insidious that it even infects our good works. Isaiah 64:6 states that our righteousness is like filthy rags to God. The reason why God sees them as filthy is that humanity uses its good works to justify itself before God. In other words, because I have done A, B & C good works, then God will over look X, Y & Z sins. The problem is that God does not weigh our sin against our good works. God is a holy God and as such He cannot overlook sin. He must deal with it in a manner that reflects His holiness. Therefore, He gave laws in the Old Testament and repeated them in the New Testament and demanded that this law be kept in deed, word and thought. In other words, the law must be kept with 100% accuracy, 100% of the time. Anything less than that is sin. God must punish sin, and He will do so by assigning all those that sin to eternity apart from Him. This is God's justice. Everyone of us has sinned, and therefore everyone of us deserves eternity apart the God who created us and demands that we worship Him.

This is the bad news. It is the black velvet. It is where every presentation of the resurrection needs to begin. It is because of our sin that God in his omniscience predestined that He would send His Son to die the death we should have died after living the life we would not live. This is the ultimate manifestation of God's love, mercy and grace. This is the diamond that is placed on the black velvet background of our sinfulness. That blackness enhances the beauty of the diamond. It makes the diamond shine brighter as it reflects God's love, mercy & grace. Jesus' death of the Roman cross, while ugly and sinful, was the manner in which we could have our sin blotted out.

The redemption story does not end there. Three days after Jesus' death He resurrected from the dead. The resurrection according to Paul was for our justification. In other words, it is the resurrection of Jesus that makes us truly righteous before God. Jesus' resurrection is the seal of approval that God placed on Jesus' death.

OK, so what? What does all of this mean now? Simply, God has provided a way out of your sin, and the subsequent eternal damnation you justly deserve. All you need to do is repent and believe. Now you have heard the real message of Easter, repent and believe in the only person who claimed to be God and proved this claim by raising from the dead. Are you willing to repent and believe?

Friday, April 15, 2011

Bible Abuse - Introduction

I have been thinking about doing this series for quite a while, and had begun doing research and outlining. I wanted to start this after I finished the Resurrection series. My laptop crashed, however, and with it all my notes on the resurrection. Yes, I know I should have backed up the files, but I didn't. So why I go back and get my research for the Resurrection series I have decided to start this new series entitled Bible Abuse.

In this new series we will be looking at various Bible verses that the cults, non-Christians and Christians use in a manner that does violence to the Scriptures. What this series will do is teach you good principles of hermeneutics by showing you how bad hermeneutics is done. It is important to understand that most misinterpretations of the Bible can be remedied by "never reading a Bible verse." I got this principle from Greg Koukl of Stand to Reason. I will be pointing this out to you as we go through the various verses when it is applicable. There are, however, other problematic issues that so many people apply to their method of Bible hermeneutics that cause faulty interpretations to surface, and we will identify them as we progress.

Before I begin, I want to define what hermeneutics is. It is both the art and science of interpreting the Bible. Hermeneutics is also something that we do everyday with all the information we read and process, from newspaper reports, to op-ed and editorial articles, to biographical works, to fiction, to non-fiction, to legal documents, etc. The genre of the literature determines the manner in which we interpret the literature. In other words, we do not interpret a legal document in the same manner as we would a comic book. The same applies to the Bible which contains a number of different genres, such as, poetry, prose, historical narrative, biography, Jewish apocalyptic, etc. The Bible is not one book that is to be interpreted in one literal and wooden manner, but rather is a collection of 66 books that are composed in different literary styles.

Secondly, the Bible was written in languages (Hebrew, Aramaic & Greek) that posses vocabulary and grammar that must be observed and followed in order to be understood. Examples of these grammatical rules are the ellipsis, and the way the writers of the New Testament would emphasize a word in the letter they were writing.

Thirdly, there have been errors in how various translating committees, especially with the King James Version, have rendered various Bible verses from the original languages into English. Because of the esteem that the KJV is held, these errors have not been corrected, though many of the modern English Bible translations have footnotes that indicate that there is a problem with the traditional rendering of a specific text.

Lastly, there has been an insertion of modern or cultural concepts into the hermeneutic style of many Biblical scholars and pastors that were completely foreign to the writers of the Old and New Testaments. An example of this is the attempt by old earth creationists to insert the concept of billions of years into the creative day.

One thing I wish to point out before I begin looking at specific Bible verses is that you, the reader, may get your interpretation of your favorite Bible verse or promise slain. Sometimes Christians, myself included, have faulty interpretations that need to be corrected. It is my prayer that you would be humble and reject faulty interpretation rather than erect an idol of your interpretation of a Bible verse. You are not alone in having faulty Bible interpretations. I have had many. Not just from my days as a Jehovah's Witness, but also from the various faulty interpretations I heard in the various churches I attended.

One last point, I do not think that I have all the answers, nor do I think that I have arrived and my knowledge of the Scriptures is complete. I have much to learn, and perhaps I have made an error in my own hermeneutics that you readers can see and correct me. I am not averse to being corrected. In fact, if I am corrected and I can verify that that I was wrong then I will change my position and post it prominently on this blog, as I have done in the past.

I also want to encourage you to post comments. I post all comments, even anonymous comments. There are one exception to the above rule, I will not post anything with profanity. Please feel free to criticize my posts, however, if you cannot express yourself without using profanity then your post is not worth reading or its author worthy of interaction.


I am looking forward to this new series, and I pray that it will be a benefit to you.

Friday, April 1, 2011

The Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, Part Four

Opposing Theories to the Resurrection

In these next few posts I will be looking at some of the opposing theories critics and skeptics use to counter the claim that Jesus actually rose from the dead. In this post, however, we will be looking at whether or not the resurrection was legend. Are the claims of the resurrection legendary embellishments from later Christians? Were the writers of the Gospels actually writing history or a non-historical account of Jesus? Do the claims of resurrections that are found in other religions discredit the claim that Jesus rose from the dead? These are the questions we will be looking at in this post.

The Resurrection “Legend”

Is the resurrection story merely a legendary embellishment that was inserted to the story over time? The problem with this claim is that is discounts the fact that the resurrection account can be traced to the original disciples. While critics and skeptics can accuse the original disciples of lying or hallucinating, they cannot claim that the resurrection was a legend that developed after the time of the disciples. The reason is that the disciples made the claim to the resurrection.

Both Paul and James came to believe in Jesus’ resurrection apart from the testimony of the disciples.

While it is true that embellishments can occur over time with stories, the issue is whether or not embellishments occurred with the resurrection claim of Christianity? Without any supporting evidence of said embellishments this theory is merely an assertion.

Non-Historical Literary Genre

Did the writers of the Gospels write in a literary style to honor their teacher as opposed to actually writing an historical account of a literal resurrection? First, the empty tomb has attestation from outside the New Testament. Second, the skeptic Paul was hostile to Christianity and a Pharisee. As a Pharisee, Paul would have been familiar with Jewish fable, and he would not have been persuaded by what he would have rightly as a feeble attempt by Christians at Jewish Midrash, nor would he follow someone he considered a false Messiah (thereby placing his own soul in jeopardy). The same issues are true with James. According to Hegesippus (as quoted by Eusebius) James remained pious towards the Jewish Law even after becoming a Christian. It would then be extremely unlikely that he would convert over a mere story he would have considered fiction, change his worldview, follow a false Messiah who was cursed by God (since Jesus was crucified), and jeopardize his soul.

We concede that the fable genre existed, we also know that historical genre existed. Merely pointing out that mythical accounts exist does nothing to demonstrate that the Christian accounts are of the same genre. When one looks at the resurrection accounts it appears that the historical genre is the most likely genre that the authors wanted to write in. For example, in Acts 2:13 David is contrasted with Jesus. In this account David’s body decayed but Jesus’ did not.

It is clear from the responses of the early critics of the church (such as Celsus and the Jewish leaders) that the primitive church believed in the resurrection of Jesus as an historical event. The responses of these critics present arguments against the view of a literal and bodily resurrection. Why argue against a literal and bodily resurrection if such was not claimed?

Resurrections in Other Religions

The accounts of rising gods in other religions are vague and unclear. Scholars do not regard these stories as parallels since the details of the accounts are vague and not similar to Jesus’ resurrection. Aesculapius was struck by lightning and ascended to heaven. Baccus and Heracles and a few other sons rose to heaven on the horse Pegasus, having died violent deaths.

The first clear parallel is 100-plus years after Jesus’ death and resurrection. That a resurrection was reported in the earlier accounts of pagan deities is questionable. There is no clear death and resurrection of Marduk. In the earliest versions of Adonis no death or resurrection is reported. There is no clear account of Osirus rising from the dead. Further accounts rising gods in other religions lack evidence and can be easily accounted for by opposing theories. In contrast, there is no opposing theory that can explain away the evidence for the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth.

In our next post we will look at another opposing theory, the “fraud” theory.

Thursday, March 24, 2011

The Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, Part Three

The Minimal Facts, Part Two
In our previous post in this series on the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, we discussed the first two of five “minimal facts” concerning the resurrection. The first of these two was that Jesus was actually put to death via the standard Roman execution method for non-Roman citizens, crucifixion. The second was that the disciples actually believed that Jesus had risen from the dead. The reader can access that post if she wishes further details as to why it is held that these are “minimal facts” of the resurrection.

In this post, we will be addressing two more of the “minimal facts” that have nearly unanimous acceptance, the conversions of Paul (a persecutor of the early followers of Jesus) and James (the skeptical brother of Jesus). We will also address the fifth “minimal fact”; the empty tomb of Jesus.

The Conversion of Saul (Paul)

The conversion of Saul/Paul is the third in our list of four plus one “minimal facts”. His conversion is an established fact in the New Testament. According to the book of Acts, Saul was a persecutor of the early followers of Christ. Luke records Saul’s approval of the stoning of the early church deacon, Stephen, and his subsequent conversion while journeying to Damascus in order to arrest and extradite followers of Jesus in that city back to Jerusalem for trial by the Sanhedrin. It was on this journey that Saul experienced the risen Jesus of Nazareth (see Acts 9, 22 & 26). Paul wrote about his conversion a number of times (1 Corinthians 15:9-10; Galatians 1:13-16; Philippians 3:6-7). This event was also a part of early Christian oral tradition circulating in Judea (Galatians 1:22-23).

Further the fact that the convert Paul suffered and was later martyred for his belief in Jesus has been attested to by Luke (Acts 14:19; 16:19-24; 17:5, 13-15; 18:12-13; 21:27-36; 23:12-35). The early church fathers such as Clement of Rome (1 Clem. 5:2-7), Polycarp (Pol. Phil. 9:2), Tertullian (Scorpiace 15; also cited by Eusebius in EH 2:25:8), Dionysius of Corinth (cited by Eusebius in EH 2:25:8), and Origen (Commentary on Genesis cited by Eusebius in EH 3:1). As well as by Paul himself (2 Cor. 11:23-28; Phil. 1:21-23).

The Conversion of James

The gospels report that Jesus’ brothers were unbelievers prior to Jesus’ resurrection (Mark 3:21, 31; 6:3-4; John 7:5). The early creed, found in 1 Corinthians mentions James (1 Cor. 15:7). Lastly, both Paul and Luke (in Acts) identify James as a leader in the Jerusalem church (Galatians 1:19; Acts 15:12-21).

Secondly, James’ suffering and persecution is attested to by Josephus (Ant. 20:200), Hegesippus (quoted at length by Eusebius in EH 2:23), and Clement of Alexandria (quoted by Eusebius in EH 2:1 and mentioned in EH 2:23).

The Empty Tomb

This final fact does not boast the near unanimous acceptance by scholars as the previous four do. According to Habermas’ research this fact is accepted by about 75% of the scholars that he studied. As with all the facts we mention, just because scholars hold to something as a fact does not “prove” anything. That being said there are three reasons why the empty tomb is treated as a fact by the vast majority of scholars.

First, if the body of Jesus was still in the tomb it would have been impossible for Christianity to even survive in Jerusalem let alone in the world. All the enemies of Jesus would have needed to have done is produce the corpse and Christianity would have died before it even began.

Secondly, there is enemy attestation to the fact that the tomb Jesus’ was buried in was empty. In claiming that Jesus’ disciples stole the body, Jesus’ enemies indirectly affirmed the empty tomb (Matthew 28:12-13; Justin Martyr, Trypho 108; Tertullian, De Spectaculis 30). If Jesus’ body was still in the tomb, then why make this claim?

Lastly, there is the testimony of the women to the empty tomb of Jesus. In the gospels, women were listed as the primary witnesses to the empty tomb. It is unlikely that the Jewish disciples of Jesus would have invented this story as women were held in low regard in the Jewish cultural context. In fact, the story that women were the first witnesses of Jesus’ resurrection would have actually damaged the claims of the disciples (Luke 24:11; Josephus, Ant. 4:8:15; Talmud: J Sotah 19a; Rosh Hashannah 1:8; Kiddushin 82b; Origen, Contra Celsum 2:59; 3:55; Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars, Augustus 44).

Further, the testimony of the women demonstrates that the resurrection was not some myth later added to the story of Jesus the “great moral teacher.” If the resurrection is merely a mythical insertion by later second or third century writers of the New Testament (as liberals, skeptics and anti-theists assert), then it makes no sense to include this embarrassing fact of women and not the male disciples being the first witnesses of the empty tomb.

These three and the previous two are five facts that must be dealt with by any opposing theory that can be used to discredit the resurrection of Jesus. In our next post we will begin looking at these opposing theories in depth and why they fail to account for one or more of these “minimal facts.”

Thursday, March 10, 2011

Reflections

Sunday (March 6th) began gloriously. I was able to attend church and hear an excellent sermon on pride. How did I know it was excellent? It kicked my butt all over the auditorium. The day continued in this vein as a discovered that Liverpool beat Manchester United 3-1 in Manchester. I was able to spend a great day with my beloved over a nice lunch. Then we went home. It was there that we were informed that a very good friend of ours passed away earlier Sunday morning after preaching at another church.

I first met Tino at the first Sunday morning church service I ever attended in 1991. The Friday before, God saw fit to save me at a Nicky Cruz evangelistic event that this church had hosted. I talked to Tino, and told him my story. I also peppered him with question after question about Christianity in general, and Pentecostalism in particular. He was very patient and answered my questions not with his opinion, but with Biblical support.


Over time, TIno and I became very good friends. As sometimes friends do we bumped heads. This was do more to me and my pride, than it was anything he did. Many times we would discuss theology and doctrine, especially as began to move from Arminianism and towards Calvinism. One of Tino's favorite topics was John MacArthur's views on the Charismatic/Pentecostal movement.


Our friendship begin as a sort of mentor/pupil and evolved to peers. I never stopped respecting him as a man of God, and a man of the Scriptures. Most importantly, I do not believe I have ever met a man as humble as he. Who put up with so much junk from others, and yet never acted out in a unchristian manner.

We also worked together in creating a sort of Christianity 101 class for people new to our church. I can't begin to tell you how much joy it brought me to teach these people about God, and to sit under Tino, and learn how to make theology more practical for people.

About a year ago, my wife and I wanted to move on to another church. I spoke to Tino a number of times about this move. He gave me a number of issues to think about, but ultimately it was time for my wife and I to leave that church and establish ourselves in a new church that was more in line with our beliefs and convictions.


A couple of weeks ago I had to stop by that church. Tino greeted me with his usual greeting, "Mr. Manning, how art thou?" We chatted for about ten minutes, and I told him that I would talk to him later. Little did I know that later will be heaven some day soon.


I will miss my friend. I grieve with my former church family as they lost a pillar. I mourn for his wife and family. One thing I do know they and I have been made better people because God saw fit to place him in our lives.

Monday, February 28, 2011

The Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, Part Two

The Four (plus one) Facts

These “facts” were determined by Gary Habermas. Habermas researched some 1,400 scholarly articles from 1975 forward. In these articles (mostly written in German, French and English), Habermas finds that there are four historical facts that receive nearly unanimous support from liberal and conservative scholars; the fifth fact has a very high level of acceptance, but it does not have the near unanimous support that the other four receive.

My own mentor, Dr. Robert Morey, has listed twelve facts in his work The Encyclopedia of Practical Christianity. I was very pleased to see these four (plus) one minimal facts of Dr. Habermas to be in the list of Dr. Morey “many infallible proofs.” For the sake of brevity, however, I will stick with Habermas' five facts.

Now what I am not saying is that just because there is scholarly agreement on these facts that the resurrection of Jesus happened. To the contrary, I am saying that based on these facts we have to come up with the best conclusion that fits the facts. Any conclusion must take into account these five facts. Any conclusion that does not account for these five facts is lacking in explanatory power and scope and must be rejected as a valid conclusion.

So what are the four (plus one) minimal facts? One, that Jesus actually died by crucifixion. Second, that Jesus’ disciples actually believed that they experienced the risen Jesus. The third fact; is the conversion of the church persecutor, Saul of Tarsus. The fourth fact is the conversion of the skeptic James. The final fact is the empty tomb. Now I want to examine these facts a bit more closely. There is quite a lot of information that I wish to share on these five points. Therefore I will be breaking this summation of the five evidences into two parts. Part one will consist of a discussion of Jesus’ death, and the belief of the disciples that Jesus resurrected form the dead. In part two, I will discuss the conversions of Paul and James, and the empty tomb.

Jesus’ Death by Crucifixion

First, this fact is reported in all four gospels. So the skeptic cannot, as some have, claim that the crucifixion was a later addition to the gospel narrative. Skeptics have done this with the resurrection account as no detailed account occurs in Mark’s Gospel. The skeptic may claim, however, that it is circular for a Christian to use the bible to prove a claim in the bible. I believe that this objection has no merit because I do not rely solely on the biblical record, but I also use sources outside the Bible.

The Ancient Jewish historian Josephus said, “When Pilate, upon hearing him accused by men of the highest standing amongst us, he had condemned him to be crucified….” (Ant. 18:3). The Roman Senator and historian Tacitus said, “Nero fastened the guilt [of the burning of Rome] and inflicted the most exquisite tortures on a class hated for their abominations, called Christians by the populace. Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus” (Annals 15:44). The Assyrian historian and satirist, Lucian of Samosata in The Death of Peregrine said, “The Christians, you know, worship this man to this day the distinguished personage who introduced their novel rites, and was crucified on that account” (11-13). In a letter residing in the British Museum we find this writing from the ancient Syrian Stoic philosopher Mara Bar Serapion, “Or [what advantage came to] the Jews by the murder of their Wise King, seeing that from that very time their kingdom was driven away from them?” There are even references to this event in Jewish religious literature as found in the Jewish Talmud, “on the eve of Passover Yeshu was hanged” (Sanhedrin 43a). Lastly, even John Dominic Crossan of the liberal Jesus Seminar stated, “That he [Jesus] was crucified is as sure as anything historical can ever be” (Jesus: A Revolutionary Biography [San Francisco: HarperCollins, 1991], 145; see also 154, 196, 201).

It is interesting to note that there are a group of fringe atheists that are stating that Jesus never existed. Based on the internal and external evidence however, it is no surprise that the mainstream of New Testament scholarship be they liberal or conservative; believe that Jesus’ death is a fact of history. These “Jesus myth” proponents are either not familiar with the evidence, or they are “cherry picking” evidence that fits their preconceptions. I will address these objections more fully at a later date.

The Disciples’ Belief That Jesus Rose from the Dead

This belief that Jesus rose from the dead was the central point of their preaching and writing. Paul stated that the disciples claimed that Jesus rose from the dead (1 Corinthians 15:9-11; Galatians 2:1-10). Paul claimed the he had an encounter with the risen Jesus (2 Cor. 10:8; 11:5; 13:10; 1 Thess. 2:6; 4:2; 2 Thess. 3:4; Philem. 1:21). This Pauline claim was acknowledged by the Apostolic Fathers (Clement of Rome [1 Clem. 5:3-5], Polycarp [Pol. Phil. 3:2; 12:1], Ignatius [Ign. Rom. 4:3]).

Further, New Testament research has discovered that the resurrection of Jesus was part of the early oral tradition of the church. 1 Corinthians 15:3-8 is a primitive early Christian creed that was used in the early Christian church:
For I delivered to you as of first importance what I also received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the Scriptures, that he was buried, that he was raised on the third day in accordance with the Scriptures, and that he appeared to Cephas, then to the twelve. Then he appeared to more than five hundred brothers at one time, most of whom are still alive, though some have fallen asleep. Then he appeared to James, then to all the apostles. Last of all, as to one untimely born, he appeared also to me.
There are some very important elements about this creed. First, it is an early testimony to the resurrection of Jesus. Secondly, it is very probably testimony from eyewitnesses to Jesus’ resurrection. Thirdly, it contains multiple testimonies to Jesus’ resurrection; Cephas/Peter, the 12, more than 500 at one time, James, all the apostles, and Paul. Lastly, it records the post-resurrection appearances of Jesus to the 12, the 500-plus, and all the apostles.

Scholars have determined that this statement is a creed based on the use of the words “delivered” and “received”. Paul is clearly communicating to the Corinthian Christians that he was giving them something he had received through oral tradition. Further, there are indications of Aramaic in this verse. The first is the use of the Greek word hoti, which was common in creeds of the day. Second the use of the Aramiac name Cephas instead of the Greek Peter since Paul was writing in Greek. Thirdly, the text is highly stylized in its use of parallelisms. Lastly, there are terms in this passage that are only found in this passage and no where else in any Pauline letters.

This creed is also dated very early by New Testament scholars. Most scholars place the date of this creed to within five years of Jesus’ death and resurrection. Jesus died around AD 30. Paul’s conversion is generally placed between AD 31 and 33. After his conversion, Paul spent three years away from Jerusalem, and after this time away, Paul then visits Peter and James in Jerusalem (Galatians 1:18-19). It is generally believed that Paul received the creed at this time.

There is another option for when Paul received this creed. It could be that he received it directly after his conversion while in Damascus. Either way Paul received this creed within two to five years after the death and resurrection of Jesus, and from someone whom Paul deemed as a trustworthy source.

The very latest date that scholars place on this creed is AD 51. Paul is writes that he received this and that he delivered this to them while he was in Corinth (1 Corinthians 15:3). This visit is dated around AD 51. Therefore Paul had the creedal information prior to his visit to Corinth and from a source he deemed trustworthy. Many skeptics will claim that the inclusion of this creed is circular since we are “quoting the bible in order to prove a claim of the bible.” Paul has a history of quoting from non-Christian sources in the New Testament (1 Corinthians 15:33; Titus 1:12; Acts 17:28), this does not, however, make them New Testament sources. The evidence presented above demonstrates that this creed did not have its origin in Paul. Therefore this creed can be claimed as a non-New Testament source.

We also have the sermon summaries found in the book of Acts (chapters 1-5, 10, 13 & 17). These sermons can be dated to within twenty years of the resurrection. There are points that are seen in these summaries. First, that there was early testimony to Jesus’ resurrection. Second, that these were possible eyewitness testimony to Jesus’ resurrection. Lastly, that these are testimonies of the group appearances (Acts 10 and 13).

Lastly, we have written tradition. All four gospels testify to Jesus’ death and resurrection. These gospels contain the multiple claims by the disciples that were written down within seventy years of the event that is central to these books.

We also have the testimony of the Apostolic Fathers, namely Clement of Rome (A.D. 95, 1 Clem. 42:3) and Polycarp (A.D. 110, Pol. Phil 9:2).

The fact that the disciples actually believed that Jesus rose from the dead is clear from a number of historical facts. These men documented their denial and abandonment of Jesus at his arrest. They were cowering in fear at the death of their leader. Something happened, however, that transformed these quivering cowards into fearless public preachers of a resurrected Jesus, even to the point of death. Luke, Clement of Rome, Ignatius, Polycarp, Dionysius of Corinth (cited by Eusebius), Tertullian, and Origen speak of disciples that fearlessly faced suffering and gruesome deaths based on the belief that Jesus rose from the dead.

I do not want to oversell this point. The willingness of the apostles to suffer and die for their testimony of the resurrected Jesus is evidence of their sincerity. These disciples truly believed that Jesus rose from the dead. Nor do I imply that their sincerity verifies the truth of their belief. There are many people that have suffered and been willing to die for various religions and causes. What their willingness to suffer, however, does demonstrate that they were not liars. Liars make poor martyrs. Since Jesus’ followers sincerely believed that he rose from the dead and appeared to them, then assertions of legends and lies do not account for the appearances of Jesus because the original apostles both claimed and believed that the risen Jesus had appeared to them.

In my next post on the Jude3blog I will discuss the conversions of Paul and James, and the empty tomb.