Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The Resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth, Part One


Christianity is not merely the collection of moral teachings and parables from Jesus of Nazareth. Much of what Jesus taught can be found in the teachings of other religious leaders that came before him. What makes Christianity unique from all other religions, however, is the claim by Jesus of Nazareth that he would be killed, but that he would be raised from the dead three days later. This resurrection of Jesus is the pivot point upon which all of Christianity revolves. The resurrection was the focus of the apostles’ preaching, as recorded in the book of Acts.

Paul, in the book of Romans, stated that belief in the resurrection of Jesus was a necessity of salvation (Romans 10:9). Peter states that the resurrection secured our inheritance in heaven (1 Peter 1:3-4). Most important, however, is Paul’s statement that if the resurrection of Jesus did not occur, then Christians are indeed lost (1 Corinthians 15:17). Not only is the resurrection the focal point of Christianity, but it was the event that Jesus pointed to in order to validate his teachings (Matthew 12:38-40; 16:1-4; John 2:18-21; cf. Mark 14:58; Luke 11:29-30). The resurrection was also the chief evidence produced by the apostles that Christianity was true (Acts 2:22-32; 3:15; 17:2-3, 18, 31; 1 Cor. 15:17). Therefore, the resurrection of Jesus confirms Jesus’ claims, Christian doctrine, and the truthfulness of Christianity (1 Corinthians 15:14).

Contrast this claim with other religions’ claims to authority. Muslims tell us that we should follow Islam because only God could have written the Qur’an. Sura 2:23 says, “And if ye are in doubt as to what We have revealed from time to time to Our servant [Muhammad], then produce a Surah like thereunto; and call your witnesses or helpers (If there are any) besides Allah, if your (doubts) are true” (cf. Surahs 10:37-38; 17:88). Dr. Anis Shorosh has demonstrated that this claim is false in his work The True Furqan. Now the Muslim may object to Dr. Shorosh’s work, and say that this Surah applies only to the Arabic of the Qur’an, but this only fails to aid their cause because the Jews can say the same of the Hebrew in the Psalms.

Mormon missionaries instruct those reading The Book of Mormon to do so with an open mind and after asking God to confirm the truth of it by some sign. This confirmation comes in the form of a “burning in the bosom.” The problem is that this sort of confirming sign could also be the result of food that did not agree with one’s stomach. In other words, it is subject to something other than God.

In either of the cases mentioned above, the tests are mutually exclusive. They are conflicting truth claims as the only way to God. Both provide different ways to God, yet both cannot be the only ways to God. This leads us to the conclusion that both claims to exclusivity of one or both of these religions are incorrect, as are their truth tests.

Christianity, however, does not rely on subjective claims such as the ones mentioned above. Christianity stands or falls on the basis of a historical fact: the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth from the dead. First, Jesus predicted his resurrection. If the resurrection happened then there is no need to dismiss Jesus’ own predictions concerning his resurrection. Second, embarrassing testimony concerning the actions of his disciples or the women at the tomb is related in the gospels. This embarrassment principle lends weight to the authenticity of the resurrection accounts found in the gospels. Third, Jesus turned the thinking of the Jewish religious leaders (and his own disciples) upside-down by his use of the Messianic title “Son of Man” in reference to his resurrection (Mark 8:31; 9:31; 10:33-34). Last, Jesus predictions of his own resurrection are referenced numerous times in the gospels: Matthew 12:38-40; 16:1-4, 21; 17:23; 20:19; Mark 8:31-32; 9:31; 10:33; Luke 9:22; John 2:18-21; cf. Mark 14:58; Luke 11:29-30.

While there are numerous pieces of evidence that support the resurrection of Jesus (Acts 1:3), it is my intention to focus on the “minimal facts” as posited by Dr. Gary Habermas. In a study of over 1,400 sources on the resurrection compiled by Dr. Habermas, he has discovered five facts that are both strongly supported evidence and are conceded by almost every scholar, even those skeptical of Christianity.

It must be understood at the outset that historical evidences do not give anyone 100% certainty, but rather provide a range of certainty from very doubtful to very certain. This lack of certainty is one of the weaknesses of evidential apologetics. This lack of certainty can be dealt with a healthy dose of presuppositional apologetics. Understand, however, that no form of apologetic will save anyone. Only the Holy Spirit can regenerate a person’s heart and cause her to make a profession of faith in Jesus as Lord and Savior.

With that said, I will be presenting the following positive argument for the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth from the dead. First, that Jesus did indeed die on a Roman cross. Second, that Jesus’ disciples sincerely believed that he rose from the dead and appeared to them. The third point, the conversions of Paul (a church persecutor) and James (a skeptic) from Judaism to Christianity. And fourth, the empty tomb. Since no plausible opposing explanation exists that can account for all four of these historical facts, the resurrection of Jesus from the dead must be the only explanation.

In our next post, I will discus the four (plus one) facts of the resurrection of Jesus of Nazareth.

Monday, February 14, 2011

St. Valentine's Day


Today is Valentine's Day. Notice how the world has removed the Saint from it? Today, Valentine's Day is just another ploy to remove cash from the wallets of men and to line the coffers of florists and candy makers. This is not just the rant of a man with an obligation on St. Valentine's Day, but just another example of how secular society has taken over something Christian.

Being an amateur historian of American history today is the anniversary of the St. Valentine's Day massacre. In which members of one Sicilian gang, led by Al Capone, in Prohibition era Chicago dressed as police officers, massacred seven members of an Irish gang in order to get control of illegal alcohol distribution in that city.

All that being said, the real story behind St. Valentine's Day is even more interesting. I have taken the story from Lutheran Hour Ministries, and I hope that it will make this day not just about showing love to your spouse, fiance, or girl/boyfriend. Instead take the time to understand that someone died on this day standing for Christ.

In 270 A.D., marriage had been outlawed by the emperor of Rome, Claudius II. Claudius issued this decree because he thought that married men made bad soldiers since they were reluctant to be torn away from their families in the case of war. Claudius had also outlawed Christianity in this time period because he wished to be praised as the one supreme god, the Emperor of Rome. Valentine was the bishop of Interamna during this period of oppression. Valentine thought that the decrees of Rome were wrong. He believed that people should be free to love God and to marry. Valentine invited the young couples of the area to come to him. When they came, Valentine secretly performed services of matrimony and united the couples.
Valentine was eventually caught and was brought before the emperor. The emperor saw that Valentine had conviction and drive that was unsurpassed among his men. Claudius tried and tried to persuade Valentine to leave Christianity, serve the Roman empire and the Roman gods. In exchange, Claudius would pardon him and make him one of his allies. St. Valentine held to his faith and did not renounce Christ. Because of this, the emperor sentenced him to a three-part execution. First, Valentine would be beaten, then stoned, and then finally, decapitated. Valentine died on February 14th, 270 A.D.
While in prison, waiting for his sentence to be carried out, Valentine fell in love with the jailer's daughter, the blind Asterius. During the course of Valentine's prison stay, a miracle occurred and Asterius regained her sight. Valentine sent her a final farewell note. He signed his last note, "From Your Valentine." Even today, this message remains as the motto for our Valentine's Day celebrations.
 As you can see, this day has far much more significance than that of a sappy romantic expression. Nor is St. Valentine's Day a time in which we make sappy romantic expressions to Jesus, as if He is our boyfriend. Sorry, single Christian ladies, but Jesus is your King. He is not some sugar daddy that you seduce or coerce to do or give you what you want.

The other dangerous thought about Jesus and St. Valentine's Day is the teaching that Jesus is the "loneliest Valentine." I heard this preached a number of times from a former pastor. Again, makes Jesus just a romantic figure at best, but at worst makes Jesus into a cat that is crying at the door begging to come in. Again, this is not the Jesus of the Bible. Jesus is King. He is sovereign over all. He rules and reigns and is not lonely, nor does he desire our companionship. He has perfect fellowship with the two other members of the Trinity. Jesus died not for the fulfillment of some loneliness, but so that His mercy and grace would be demonstrated for all to see. This is not a boyfriend.

So when giving your sweetheart flowers or chocolates today, why not tell him/her about the true meaning of St. Valentine's Day. That on this day someone died for Christ and marriage, and that is why we commemorate this day.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Is Tithing for Christians? Part Seven


New Testament Giving

So far in this series, we have shown from the bible that tithing was a part of the Old Testament and as such Christians are not under any obligation to pay tithes. We have also looked at all the Old Testament proof texts that are consistently used by tithing advocates to promote tithing. We also see that the curse, as found in Malachi 3, is strictly associated with the Mosaic Law. This Law was nailed, along with Christ Jesus, to the Roman cross. As such the curse along with the tithe was fulfilled by Jesus’ death.

We have looked at how the tithe was viewed in the New Testament. It is clear that the tithe was not viewed in high esteem by Jesus. The reason was simple; tithing was, and is, a way in which religious people could parade their righteousness in front of others and God. We will look more at this aspect of tithing later in this post.

No Rules for Giving

The main point of this post is to examine giving in the light of the New Testament.  The first thing that Christian’s should understand is that looking for “hard and fast” rules is a futile search. Rules tend to make things nice and neat. What happens with rules, however, is that instead of being a fence to protect one from danger, they become walls to separate Christians from other Christians. Each new rule simply vindicates a professed Christians’ self-righteousness. I have heard this from one of the church pastors that is a key leader in that movement’s top leadership. This pastor required that members not only be tithers, but in order to be moved up into leadership they be double tithers! This is not how church leadership is to be determined (Titus 1:5-9; 1 Timothy 3:1-10; 12-13).

The good thing about rules is that they give clear indications of another’s spirituality to others. It gives people the minimum requirements that good people need to live by. The problem with living by rules, however, is that they lead to a Pharisiacal attitude. For instance, if ten percent is the bare minimum one can give, then if I give more than ten percent I am more spiritual than one who does. Tim Keller describes this in his book The Reason for God:

The tendency of religious people ... is to use spiritual and ethical observance as a lever to gain power over others and over God, appeasing him through ritual and good works. This leads to both an emphasis on external religious forms as well as greed, materialism, and oppression in social arrangements (p. 59).

What Keller describes above is the only result of legalistic religion.

Attitude is the Goal of New Testament Giving

New Testament giving is not about duty but attitude. New Testament giving is to be liberal and with the goal of demonstrating a generous heart rather than the paying of a tax. John speaks of giving as a natural outflow and evidence of loving (1 John 3:16-18). Paul commended the church in Phillipi for their gift to him, and stated that it was evidence of their growth in Christ (Phillipians 4:16-17).

Paul told the church in Corinth that Christian giving should be cheerful, not begrudgingly or under compulsion (2 Cor. 9:7). Christian giving should not be based on emotional manipulation or pressure, but on a clear decision to give. New Testament is an act of trust in a God who supplies all of our needs according to His riches and glory in Christ Jesus. The Greek word translated “cheerful” is hilaros from which we get the English word hilarious. New Testament giving should make a Christian hilariously happy. Contrast this attitude with the emotional manipulation and compulsory payment of a tithe. Further New Testament giving should be based on the income of the individual believer (2 Cor. 8:11-12). If a person can afford to give a tenth (or more, or less) is solely a matter of conscience. Based on this it is incumbent on church leaders and pastors to be careful to not place undue pressure on church members, nor tell them how much to give, i.e., ten percent.

Stewardship

The New Testament view of finances is to be that of stewardship. In other words, Christians will make an account of everything they have been gifted with, including finances. This is what Jesus speaks of in the parable of the talents as found in Matthew 25:14-30. What Jesus warned against was wasting opportunities because no one gets a second chance. The purpose of stewardship is to manage the resources given in the best way possible. If one’s attitude about giving is based on one’s attitude, then giving, as a practice, loses its value as a religious deed.

Unforced Giving

Unforced giving is the voluntary transfer of wealth from the well-off to the less well-off. This includes, but is not limited to, the sharing of meals with people one would not normally eat with. What the New Testament calls philoxenia, literally “the love of strangers, is the natural outworking of love (1 John 3:16-18). This word is also found in Hebrews 13:2; Romans 12:13; 1 Peter 4:9; 3 John 5-8; c.f. 2 John 10-11. This love of strangers is also a requirement for elders in the church (1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 3:2). This requirement of hospitality is a requirement for widows seeking assistance from the church (1 Timothy 5: 10). Further Scripture requires that the weak ones in the church be borne up by the strong, in other words the church is to help those that are unable to support themselves. This is especially applicable to the widow, the orphan, and those that labor for the sake of the gospel.

Supporting the Poor

There are two areas in which Christians are to give: the poor and those who labor for the sake of the gospel. The “poor” is defined by Scripture as the widow and the orphan. This is so important to the first century church that James calls the care of the widow and the orphan as “pure and undefiled religion” (James 1:27). In the time of the writing of the New Testament, to be a widow or an orphan meant that you had no one supporting you and that meant that you would probably die of hunger. Today, this scripture can be applied to mean that no widow or orphan should have to rely on the government dole for their subsistence.

It is interesting to note that the first century church was the first “welfare state” (Acts 6:1-3). The difference between then and now is that back then the wealth transfer was voluntary and based on the confiscation of income under the power of the law. This provision was not demonstrated by the paying of tithes or through gleaning, but in a daily provision (Acts 4:34-35). That this provision was based on voluntary giving and not compulsory tithing is evidenced by Peter’s rebuke of Ananias (Acts 5:4).

Further Scripture admonishes Christians to honor widows who are widows indeed (1 Timothy 5:3). Scripture then describes for us how widows qualify for church assistance: they had to have neither children nor grandchildren (1 Timothy 5:3), they must be over the age of 60 while younger widows were to remarry (1 Timothy 5:4-16). Lastly, church assistance was always in additional to individual members’ generous gifts to these people.

Supporting Those Who Rule and Teach the Church

The second area of Christian giving is to those who labor for the sake of the gospel. There are a number of Scriptures that deal with giving to those who labor for the gospel. Just as in the Old Testament where the Levites were called to abandon all other manners of employment, and were to be supported by the people they ministered to, so to the church is to support the elders that rule over them (1 Cor. 9:13-14). We see that Jesus abandoned the trade of his father (carpenter), and his disciples abandoned their trades to follow Jesus and were supported by others (Luke 8:3). The apostle John encouraged this sort of giving (3 John 5-8), as did Paul (Galatians 6:6; 1 Corinthians 9:11). It is clear from New Testament scripture that the hearers were to support the one that was teaching them.

Final Thoughts

The conclusion of the matter of New Testament giving is to that it is strictly a matter of attitude and not action. New Testament giving is to be marked by hilarious volunteerism as opposed to begrudged taxation. This is why Christians must give as opposed to tithe. The difference is attitude. Attitude is what marks the life of a Christian. Are you motivated by love for God, or by the love of men? Most of the tithing advocates I have ever heard speak on the giving tend to speak of tithing as something to beat God into obedience to our wills. This is not the purpose of giving. Giving is to cause us to divorce ourselves from the idol of money, and focus on the propagation of the gospel and the expansion of the kingdom of God.

With all this in mind, what should your attitude be about tithing? Simply put, tithing is not for Christians, and is not something that Christians should be participating in. Not that Christians are excused from giving rather Christians are excused from tithing. Tithing is a relic of the Old Testament, and should remain there. Sadly, too many Christian pastors use tithing to beat their members over the head to get them to give either out of a sense of obligation or a sense of fear. This ought to never be done in the Christian church. Tithing is, as the picture at the beginning of this post states, the pastor's law and not the Lord's law.

On the other hand, what should a Christian’s attitude be about giving? Simply put, a Christian’s attitude about giving should be gratitude, joy and liberality. A Christian should also remember that the majority of her giving should go to one of two areas; the poor and those who labor for the gospel. These two areas are scripturally mandated, that does not mean, however, that Christians are excused from other forms of giving. Ultimately, Christian giving is dictated by the conscience and financial circumstances of the individual Christian, and no one, no pastor, no self-proclaimed apostle or prophet, and not even another Christian should impose their personal views of giving on another Christian.

It is my prayer that this series has been both educational and a blessing to you. I pray that those in tithe advocating churches will look at the tithe scripturally and apply scripture to the tithe and move from obligatory tithing to joyous and generous giving. If you had questions about the tithe, I hope that your doubts have been laid to rest. I know that I wish I had something like this when I first heard of tithing and the curse. It would have eliminated a lot of unnecessary guilt in my life.

Our next series on the Jude3blog will be dealing with the resurrection of Jesus.

Friday, February 4, 2011

Is Tithing for Christians? Part Six

The Tithe in the New Testament

We have established that the tithe is strictly an Old Testament institution with specific instructions that applied to the Israelites under the Mosaic Law. We have even looked at a few arguments for the tithe, and found them wanting. Yet tithing advocates will not stop at a refutation from the Old Testament. They will occasionally pull out the New Testament in order to justify this unbiblical teaching. So let’s see what the New Testament says about the tithe.

Focused on the Minors

The New Testament mentions the tithe nine times. The first two instances in the New Testament are nearly identical. They are found in Matthew 23:23 (ESV):

“Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you tithe mint and dill and cumin, and have neglected the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faithfulness. These you ought to have done, without neglecting the others.”

And Luke 11:42 (ESV):

"But woe to you Pharisees! For you tithe mint and rue and every herb, and neglect justice and the love of God. These you ought to have done, without neglecting the others.”

These two passages are nearly alike with Luke adding the names of various herbs and the “neglect…[of] the love of God.” What we see from these two passages is that Jesus commended the religious people’s attention to same and insignificant details of the Law, but rebukes them for their ignoring of the meat of the Law, namely justice, mercy, faithfulness and the expression of God’s love into the lives of others. To many times I have seen Christians who faithfully tithe consistently miss opportunities to meet the needs of those around them because they feel that they are “paid up” with God by tithing and the needs of their brothers and sisters in Christ are left unmet, or worse members of the church are forced to turn to the government for assistance! A Christian who has fallen on hard times should never have to turn to the government for assistance as can be read in James.

The Parable of the Pharisee and the Tax Collector

The next mention of tithing is found in Luke 18:12. This verse is part of Jesus’ parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector. In this parable we see Jesus juxtaposing the religious person reliant on his righteousness with the person reliant on God’s grace. In this instance Jesus refers directly to the Mosaic Law, but not in a good light. Here the Pharisee appears to demand that God regard his prayer over the tax collector on the basis of his righteousness. Isn’t this what we see and hear time and time again from tithing advocates? They speak of the tithe as something that God has to respect and comply with, as if God is some political lackey that must do the bidding of the highest donor.

Tithing in the Book of Hebrews

The other six times that the tithe is found in the New Testament is in Hebrews 7:4-10 (ESV):

“See how great this man was to whom Abraham the patriarch gave a tenth of the spoils! 5Andthose descendants of Levi who receive the priestly office have a commandment in the law to take tithes from the people, that is, from their brothers, though these also are descended from Abraham. 6But this man who does not have his descent from them received tithes from Abraham and blessed him who had the promises. 7It is beyond dispute that the inferior is blessed by the superior. 8In the one case tithes are received by mortal men, but in the other case, by one of whom it is testified that he lives. 9One might even say that Levi himself, who receives tithes, paid tithes through Abraham, 10for he was still in the loins of his ancestor when Melchizedek met him.”

Before we look at this passage, we must understand what was the theme of the Book of Hebrews; namely, the superiority of Jesus Christ to the ceremonial Law of Moses. The theme of chapter seven is to establish the superiority of the Melchizedik priesthood, which Jesus is the High Priest, over the Levitical priesthood. Since Jesus is seen as the fulfillment of Melchizedik by the writer of Hebrews, then it follows that Jesus is superior to the Levite high priest.

Lastly, if we are going to use Abraham’s tithe to Melchizidek as an example for Christian tithing, then it is clear that there is a misunderstanding of what the writer of Hebrews was communicating. First, the person paying the tithe is inferior to the one receiving the tithe. Second, even though the Jewish priests received tithes from the tithe that the Levites received from the people, these priests never paid tithes. Third, Jesus, in the book of Hebrews is portrayed as a priest that is superior to the Levitical priests. As Christians, we are co-priests with Jesus, and likewise superior to the Levitical priests. Therefore, based on the above, individual Christians should be receiving tithes. This however, is not what tithe advocates teach. Why? Because they are interested in one thing and one thing only, your money!

The question that is asked to me next is the question I will deal with in my next post; what is New Testament giving?

Next on the blog: New Testament Giving.

Monday, January 24, 2011

Is Tithing for Christians? Part Five

Four Arguments for Tithing Refuted

So we have dealt with tithing in the Old Testament, and by the use of exegesis and logic we see that tithing, as found in the Old Testament, is only obligatory on those that are under the Old Covenant. Some will say that because Abraham paid a tithe to Melchizedek prior to the institution of the tithe under Moses that Christians are under the obligation to pay the tithe. We ask, however, whether or not these tithe teachers are circumcised? Was not Abraham circumcised prior to the Mosaic requirement? How about taking concubines? Did not Abraham take concubines? Should we follow that example? These tithe teachers simply smile in embarrassment as their logic is demonstrated as faulty.

Under the Mosaic Law there was only one tithe commanded by God. This tithe was on a three year cycle. The first two years of the cycle the tither was to take his tithe to Jerusalem and use it to support him and his house during the week in which they celebrated the Festival of Booths. The third year, the tither was to take the tithe to the city gate, and leave it. This tithe was then used by the Levite, the widow, the orphan and the alien in the land.

In Malachi we see God speaking of cursing the land of Israel because they were not paying the third year tithe. By doing this they had not properly disposed of “the sacred portion” and in doing so the returning Jews brought the curse of the Law upon them.

Even with all this said, people who are still wedded to their tradition of tithing will ignore the clear biblical teaching and offer arguments to support tithing. In this post I will address four of them.

The After Sabbath Collection

Now concerning the collection of the saints, you should follower the directions I gave to the churches in Galatia. After the Sabbath ends, each of you should set aside and save something from your surplus in proportion to what you have, so that no collections will be made when I arrive (1 Cor. 16:1-2, International Standard Version).

The question must be asked, “Does this verse recognize the shift from a rural agrarian economy to an urban business economy, and compel a weekly tithe from the church?” The answer is, “No!” The reason is simple. The direction we cited above has a specific purpose, namely, relief for the brothers and sisters in Jerusalem (1 Cor. 16:3). If anything, this verse supports the idea that special offerings can be received by the church elders for specific projects or purposes. In the instance quoted above, however, we see that this collection was added to the collection received from the church in Macedonia (2 Cor. 8:1-4; 1 Cor. 16:5). This collections was specifically for the poor (Romans 15:26-27). This collection was similar to one that was taken up in Antioch (Acts 11:27-30).

Since this collection was a one-time event (2 Cor. 8:14), and it was a collection that lasted about one year (2 Cor. 8:10; 9:2), this scripture is not a systematic teaching about tithing in the church, but rather a special offering given for a specific purpose. This offering was a generous, loving and voluntary redistribution of wealth from both wealthy and poor Gentile followers of Christ to distressed Jewish followers of Messiah in Jerusalem.

Not Teaching Tithing Gives People an Excuse for Not Giving

No, what I am presenting gives people an excuse for not tithing. Jesus said in Luke 14:33, that in order be one of his followers a person must give up ALL his possessions. In other words, a person must recognize God’s sovereignty over all her finances, and not just ten percent. A follower of Christ must understand that she is merely a manager of God’s money and God’s property.

The tithe, on the other hand, teaches a person that he merely has to “pay God off” with ten percent and with that done God has no say in how the remaining 90 percent is handled. Christians are taught to meet the needs of others, especially fellow Christians (1 John 3:16-18). In my personal experience with members of tithing churches, is that while they speak highly of giving to God they are very stingy when meeting the needs of fellow believers who are in need.

Tithing is a Starting Point

Many tithing advocates will point to Galatians 3:24, and state that tithing is an excellent starting point to begin a life of Christian giving. If anyone understood the Law it was Paul. In this passage however, he is speaking on how the Law pointed the way to Christ. He is not saying that the Law pointed Christians to Christ, but that in order to have a starting place turn back to the Law. In fact, Paul was teaching the opposite.

Paul stated that the Law failed because of human weaknesses. Grace succeeds where the Law failed because Christians have the empowering of the Holy Spirit to help us in our weaknesses (Romans 8:3-5). Shouldn’t Christians trust the Holy Spirit and God’s word to teach us about giving rather than pointing back to the Law that was weak? Is not tithing merely relying on man’s wisdom rather than trusting God’s foolishness (1 Cor. 2:5)? The answer is clear, tithing is not a starting point, but is in reality a legalistic rule being imposed on unsuspecting Christians by predatory pastors motivated by greed and not by love.

Why Was I Blessed When I Tithed, but Not Blessed When I Held Back?

This was always a big objection for me. I have heard this question so many times that if I had a nickel for every time I heard it I would be a very rich man. What this question boils down to is whether or not something is true because it works. This is a philosophy called pragmaticism, and it is the lone American entry into the world of philosophy. As Christians, however, we are not to judge the truth of a teaching or idea by whether it works or not. A Christian philosophy says that if something is true, then it will work. Now this idea can be turned around by tithing advocates who will say, “See, tithing is taught in the Bible, and it works. Therefore tithing should be practiced by Christians. Is this the case?

God is consistent in blessing those that honor Him. If God blesses those who pay tithes it is not because of the tithe, but in spite of the tithe. God is honoring the motive behind the tithe. Further, the issue is not tithing, but rather the conscience. If a Christian has been incorrectly taught that tithing is something she ought to do, then she must conscientiously tithe. To not tithe would be a violation of her conscience, and according to Romans 14:22-23, she would be committing sin. It is to these Christians that I am addressing these series of posts.

Christians who have been taught that tithing is a Christian obligation must be re-educated to understand that the Christian standard is not tithing, but freely motivated giving. I am also writing to pastors that are teaching the necessity tithing; that they would reevaluate their human tradition and bring their teaching back under the covering and protection of Scripture.

In the next post: The Tithe and the New Testament.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Is Tithing for Christians? Part Four

Tithing and the Curse

Now we are coming down to the meat of all the tithing messages that I have ever heard; the Malachi curse. I will be getting into that verse in depth, but I have a passage that I wish to discuss because much of what is said in it confirms what I have already written about regarding the tithe as laid out in Deuteronomy. This passage is one that I have never heard preached on in any tithing message I have heard, and for good reasons.

Amos’ Rebuke

Amos is a pre-Babylonian exile prophetic book that gives us a taste of some of Amos’ preaching to the wayward Israelites. In Amos 4:4-5, we find the first mention of tithing in the Old Testament prophetic books. What we find is that in their zeal for pagan worship the Israelites were paying tithes to the false gods they worshipped, as opposed to every third year as prescribed in Deuteronomy.

It is interesting to me that so many pastors, who advocate the tithe, advocate it in a religious manner. In fact, I heard one pastor speak about what you owe if you miss paying tithes off one pay cycle. He said that from the next paycheck, a tithing person owes another 20% interest on the tithe he missed. Obviously this pastor was making God an advocate of exorbitant interest rates that even this pastor would in no way, shape, or form pay creditors!

Malachi’s Curse

This is the passage used by pastors who believe in enforced giving. This passage is used to beat those who do not tithe into thinking that tithing will somehow stop God from blessing their lives. Not tithing, it is said, not only stops God from blessing you, but it gives the enemy the right to curse the non-tithers finances, health, and other areas of life.

This use of highly emotional language is often a key part of any sermon given by any pastor that believes that the curse in Malachi is applicable to Christians.

Before we go into this book further, we must also explore the historical context that surrounded Malachi’s preaching. Malachi is in the post-Babylonian exile prophetic books. It is part of three books that show samples of the Holy Spirit inspired preaching of the day. These books are also to be read in light of the post-Babylonian history books, in particular Nehemiah 10:37-38.

The question must be asked, however, whether or not those under the New Covenant are under any of the curses described in the Old Testament curses. As we have stated in previous posts, the Old Testament never make the requirement that the tithe be given away. Ironically, Malachi confirms the fact that there were two tithes, and that the tithe in question was the third year tithe.

So let’s look at the passage in question, Malachi 3:6-12 (ESV):

"For I the Lord do not change; therefore you, O children of Jacob, are not consumed. 7 From the days of your fathers you have turned aside from my statutes and have not kept them. Return to me, and I will return to you, says the Lord of hosts. But you say, 'How shall we return?' 8 Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, 'How have we robbed you?' In your tithes and contributions. 9 You are cursed with a curse, for you are robbing me, the whole nation of you. 10 Bring the full tithes into the storehouse, that there may be food in my house. And thereby put me to the test, says the Lord of hosts, if I will not open the windows of heaven for you and pour down for you a blessing until there is no more need. 11 I will rebuke the devourer for you, so that it will not destroy the fruits of your soil, and your vine in the field shall not fail to bear, says the Lord of hosts. 12 Then all nations will call you blessed, for you will be a land of delight, says the Lord of hosts.

What are the main points of this passage? First, Israel had robbed Yahweh by not giving to the third year tithe to the Levites as required by the Mosaic Law. Second, the consequence for their disobedience was that the “windows of heaven” were closed to them. Third, a curse was pronounced on their land by Yahweh. Fourth, Israel must respond with the whole tithe in order to have the curse lifted. Finally, this tithe was to be brought into the Temple storehouse.

How is this passage to be understood? Is this passage linked to any other passages, particularly in the Mosaic Law? There is a direct parallel found in Deuteronomy 26:12-15 (ESV):

"When you have finished paying all the tithe of your produce in the third year, which is the year of tithing, giving it to the Levite, the sojourner, the fatherless, and the widow, so that they may eat within your towns and be filled, 13 then you shall say before the Lord your God, 'I have removed the sacred portion out of my house, and moreover, I have given it to the Levite, the sojourner, the fatherless, and the widow, according to all your commandment that you have commanded me. I have not transgressed any of your commandments, nor have I forgotten them. 14 I have not eaten of the tithe while I was mourning, or removed any of it while I was unclean, or offered any of it to the dead. I have obeyed the voice of the Lord my God. I have done according to all that you have commanded me. 15 Look down from your holy habitation, from heaven, and bless your people Israel and the ground that you have given us, as you swore to our fathers, a land flowing with milk and honey.'

Only when Malachi is contrasted with Deuteronomy can we understand what Malachi was inspired to preach against. The Israelites were instructed to declare that the “Sacred portion” had been removed from the home of the tither. They called on Yahweh to look down on them from His heaven and they called on Him to bless the people of Israel and their land which He had given them.

Malachi was preaching against Israel’s failure to pay the tithe, as required by the Law, and pronouncing the consequences of said failure against the people. The consequences of robbing Yahweh were that the windows of heaven were shut to them, and that they were not able to live under God’s blessing, but rather they had to suffer under God’s curse. With this in mind it is therefore necessary to conclude that the curse spoken of in Malachi applies only to those that were under the Mosaic Law, and it does not apply to any believer that is under the New Covenant.

The purpose of teaching the tithing curse is NOT to cause God to bless those that give. Rather this curse teaching was designed by greedy pastors that do not want to work, but would rather have people support their lavish lifestyles.



The Punishing Tithe

This tithe can be found in 1 Samuel chapter 8. This tithe is the consequence of Israel’s desire to have an earthly king to rule over them. This tithe was essentially a tax levied on the people by the king in order to support his family and the kingdom. Interestingly, this tithe is closer to what so many pastors demand from their parishioners than what the Mosaic Law described.

Another interesting fact regarding this tithe is that this passage was used by the Roman Catholic Church to support the concept of tithing since at least the 6th century A.D. This concept was also carried on by the Protestant churches, and is especially prevalent in Pentecostal churches.

Concluding the Matter

Ultimately, it is clear that any pastor who teaches the tithe and uses Malachi 3 as a stick to beat his congregation into submission is guilty of ripping this Scripture out of its proper context and shoving it into the New Covenant. I will discuss what New Covenant giving consists of in future posts, but for now it is clear that there is no president for this sort of enforced giving to be imported into the church. There is no reason for any believer to think that God will curse them if they do not tithe. It is my hope and prayer that believers in these sorts of churches will prayerfully consider their future in these churches. It is also my prayer that pastors who may read this blog will reconsider their traditional teaching on tithing, and instead go back to the Biblical teaching of giving.

Next on the blog: Responses to various arguments for tithing.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Suggestions for 2011 & When Traditions Trump Scripture

While I have an entire spectrum of ideas I can write about, and I will be finishing the Tithing series this month, I wanted to throw the doors open to my tens and tens of readers for topic suggestions in 2011. I hope that these will be topics that you have questions about, or questions that you have not received a satisfying answer for. Now, I am not saying that I can give satisfying answers to many questions or topics, but I will try to look at them through the Christian worldview and answer them accordingly. So please post some suggested topics below. Thanks in advance.

When Tradition Trumps Scripture

This has been a topic I have been thinking about since the hearing James White's on The Dividing Line on New Year's Eve day. In that dividing line he refuted an Arminian Baptist's poor attempt at refuting The Doctrines of Grace, also known as, Calvinism. While this speaker's refutation was poor, there was something that really stuck with me. Dr. White stated that the poor exegesis (the drawing out of the meaning of Scripture) demonstrated by this Arminian Baptist is a direct result of allowing tradition to trump Scripture.
The Arminian Baptist consistently took Scripture out of context (Romans 8:28-32), emphasized the wrong words (2 Peter 3:9), denied the clear teaching of Scripture (Romans 9:10-13), and he persisted in a blatant misrepresentation of the Calvinist position. All of these things I have come to expect from my Arminian brothers, after all, as this particular Arminian Baptist stated over and over again, Calvinism is a pernicious false doctrine that need not even be examined. Of course, anyone who is involved in so-called discernment ministries ask, "How can anyone properly refute a topic that one has not properly researched?" Further, when a person simply applies the basic rules of grammar to the Arminian's proof texts their doctrine falls apart like a sand castle when it is beset by the rising tide.
The saddest point with many Arminians, and many others within Christianity that hold to non-biblical doctrines (by non-biblical, I mean doctrines that have no clear biblical foundation, as opposed to unbiblical, which are doctrines that are contrary to the clear teaching of scripture) is that they allow their tradition to trump scripture. This should never be the case. Our traditions are always defined by scripture. Of course many within this branch of Christianity would proudly crow about not having traditions, however, this is a tradition in and of itself.

So with this in mind, I have had to ask myself, and I ask you, the reader, to examine what traditions you have that are trumping scripture, and what will you do with them should you find them? Here are a couple of traditions that are especially prevalent in Christianity, especially at the beginning of the year. Perhaps your church passed out handouts giving you a plan on how to read the entire bible the whole year? Or maybe they hand out a checklist, a sort of "spiritual to-do" list of various spiritual disciplines such as prayer, bible reading, fasting, church attendance, tithing, etc. These things are not full of grace, but rather they are elements of legalism. Legalism is the doing of any good thing with the thought that the act will ingratiate God to us. Worse yet, if you do not do these things God will love you less. My friends this is the epitome of legalism, and do not let anyone mature Christian, church leader or even a church pastor tell you different!

I am not against bible reading or spiritual disciplines, they are, in fact, a natural fruit of a changed heart. A changed heart will want to read the God's word; it will want to communicate with God through prayer; it will want to give finances joyfully and without compulsion; it will want to seek out a community of fellow believers and actively fellowship with them; it will motivate you to fast when the times of life require a special time of separation from the world. It is clear, however, that there are churches and leaders that have taken these good things and made them ultimate things, as Timothy Keller puts it. In other words, they are made idols that we sacrifice to in the hope that God will no longer be angry with us over our sin. In reality, however, we have sinned in that we, in the act of spiritual devotion, have created an idol.

Again, traditions are not necessarily bad things. Perhaps you come from a church with a tradition of emphasizing traditions or spiritual disciplines. It is your responsibility as a believer to examine the tradition or discipline regardless of who taught your the tradition or discipline (Acts 17:11). Secondly, if your tradition or discipline becomes an ultimate thing, then you must repent of your idolatry. Lastly, I am not telling you to go up to your leader or pastor and tell him that he is preaching idolatry. Perhaps he or she has not had his/her conscience trained properly, or maybe he/she is just ignorant of the scriptural teachings, or, and this is the worst case scenario, perhaps he/she is is so devoted to their tradition that she absolutely will not change. What we must understand is that in this area we are dealing with the conscience, and these areas must be handled delicately, or better yet given to God in prayer.
My purpose is not to change people that can not or will not change, but rather to help those that are willing to examine themselves and make the necessary changes. So I end this post with the question, are you willing to change?